The Process of Placing Alien Physics in the Seguin Guadalupe County Public Library

A good friend of mine took a novel that he wrote to the local public library several months before I completed my book and later told me that his book had a following and had been checked out about 12 times. When I got copies of my finished book comparing scientific and Christian cosmology, I took one to the same local library on October 17, 2002. The lady at the desk asked if I had written the book and I said yes. She then thanked me for the contribution. I then checked back into the library about a month later and could not find it on the card catalog and I inquired at the desk about when it might be placed and cataloged. She said it was in the back and would soon be placed. Then about another month later I checked on the book from the internet and found my friend's novel but not my book.

Monday morning 2/3/03, I went into the library and checked the computer catalog. My book was not to be found. I went to the desk where three smiling librarian women asked if they could help me. I told them my problem. They looked it up on Amazon.com and found it. They looked on their catalog and could not find it. None of them were smiling anymore nor even responding to idle comments regarding the book quantity that seems to remain the same on the floor. They said my book was in the back and that only one person catalogs books. But this time I was determined to find out what was going on. I asked to go back into this room and find my book. One lady said just a moment and went to the back. She later came out and said come on in and there I met Ms. Jacki Gross, the Library Manager. She said sit down and I will tell you the book contribution policy. She said I am the one with responsibility to determine what is cataloged and goes on the shelf.

I looked for your book and it is not there. She said when I determine that the book does not fit our "reading public," it goes out in the lobby for sale. She said the age and condition of the book is critical. She quickly realized that was of no help as my book was brand new.

I asked her how my friend's novel could get on the shelf but my book could not as his was trash. My friend describes his book, when asked, as "600 dirty pages." I told Ms. Gross that I was amazed that I can't get a book about Christian cosmology on the shelf but my friend could get his trash on the shelf. I said there are other books about the cosmos in here. She said she was sorry if I was offended. I asked her if she would put my book on the shelf if I brought her another copy and she said she could not guarantee that.

She would have to determine if it "fits the local reading public." I said I was amazed and hardly knew what to say. I asked if she knew me or my name or something. She asked my name again and said no, should I? I said, well, I write stuff in the paper from time to time. I said I want to make sure people know the policy of contributing books to the library. She said I don't set the policy, would you like to talk to Mr. Mark Gretchen, the Head Librarian, and I replied no, and got up and walked out of her office. After three steps out, I quickly returned and asked for her name again and she gave me a card. I turned again and as I walked away, I could hear her say, do you write for the Gazette? I said nothing more.

I returned to the local public Library that afternoon of 2/3/03 about 1:30PM. Ms. Gross was surprised to see me and said she did not expect me back so soon as I invited myself into her office. I said, yes, well I want to get this worked out real soon. I gave her my letter addressed to the editor that I wrote that morning, as I said, maybe we can agree on what happened this morning. As she began to read, I said I will go get my friend's book off the shelf to compare with mine while you're reading.

I found my friend's book and returned to her office to find her on the phone with, I presume Mr. Mark Gretchen, the Head Librarian. I over heard her say that he said the girl at the desk asked if he had written the book and he had said yes. The rest of her conversations were just yes and no etc. She hung up and she said we don't have to agree to the content of this letter to the editor and I agreed. She returned the letter to my side of the desk and she said are you trying to bribe me with this letter to put your book on the shelf? I replied, well yeah, if that what it takes! I just can't believe it should take all of this to get my book on the shelf when my friend had no trouble at all.

I pushed my book over to her and said let's review this book now and see just what it is that does not meet the criteria of the library here. I said we should get out the review form and go over it. Ms. Gross said she didn't have a form and I was surprised. She said, I have a Masters degree in Library Administration, I mean I went to school for this, I'm qualified to make these decisions. I said that's fine but how do you determine what goes and what stays? She said when she purchases books she first reads all the reviews from publishers and journals etc, and your book doesn't have any reviews does it. I replied, no, as I held up my friend's book, and said this book doesn't have any reviews either. How did it get in here without a review article? I said I know everything about this book, the author is my friend and I see him everyday.

She said, what would make you happy Mr. Avery, and I replied, just put the book on the shelf and load it on the computer catalog. She said she would have to review it. I said alright, then I will just leave this new copy here with you but if you don't like it don't sell it for 50 cents out on the sidewalk, call me on the phone and I'll come pick it up. I also said that if my book does not meet the placement criteria, I want to know why when I come to get it. . I started to give her my number but said I'm probably on your computer and she looked up my name and found that my library card had expired. I said well my name is right on the cover and she said that doesn't make you a celebrity, just because you write a few letters to the editor. I replied that I was not saying I was a celebrity but just trying to show her that my name was on the cover and that I was a resident of Seguin. I got up and said I will return my friend's book to your shelf and she said no that's OK I will put it back and I said alright, I will wait for your call to see if my book meets all the criteria and I left the office with my letter.

I visited our Seguin Guadalupe County Public Library again at 11:30 AM on the following day, 2/4/03, to see if Ms. Jacki Gross had reviewed my book yet and if it was going to be acceptable for the shelf. When I arrived I went to her open door where she saw me, but she was on the phone so I looked at books on the cart close by to find all kinds of paper back books. My book is a paper back too. When she got off the phone I stuck my head in the door and said good morning, I came by to see if you had decided on my book yet. She said Mr. Avery this might come as a surprise to you but you are just not priority around here. I asked why not? I said, I am a local resident standing at the door, why would I not be a priority? She said just look at all these books I have to go through. There were books stacked all around her office but my book was still on her own desk on top of my friend's book right in front of her.

I said, I'm sorry but I'm beginning to take this personal. I asked her why she couldn't just look at the book and tell me if it can go on the shelf. She said well unlike your friend's book that you claim is just dribble, it's a fiction book and accuracy is not a question. She said but your book is a non-fiction book and can be reviewed for accuracy. I asked if she reviewed the accuracy of all non-fiction books and she said no. She said, OK Mr. Avery, I took a look at your web site last night and took your book home with me and I read the back cover and the "about the author" page where it said you're a space alien (she said this with a grinning smirk on her face). I said yes ma'am, I am, is there a problem with the accuracy on that? She did not answer that question. She said, I read the front part with the Preface, Dedication and Acknowledgements and that's as far as I got. I asked if there was a problem in there somewhere and she said no.

I said, then I just don't get why this is such a problem. She said I just don't like you coming in here and threatening me with a letter to force me to put your book on the shelf. I said I'm not threatening you with any thing, it's not illegal to write a letter to the editor. I said, you can write your own letter to the editor and tell him how nasty I am for coming in here with my book and wanting it to be put on the shelf like my other friend did. She said, I don't like you coming in here every day about your book, you told me to call you when acceptance would be determined. I said well can you give me some kind of date at when I could expect an answer. She said I don't know. I said, well I have to take that as a no on acceptance. She said, I didn't say that. I said, well then why should I have to wait eternally for an answer? She said, OK then, how about April the 30th. I said, wow OK that's good. She said I will write it on my calendar and she opened it up and I watched her write it down in her calendar. I asked, that's this year right, 2003? She said yes. I said that's super I will not return to see you until then. I went to the car and wrote that in my calendar as well.

I don't believe this sweet girl would read this book any other way. She will be blessed if she reads it all, so I thank my Alienor who has made me an Alienee. May Christ Jesus be glorified in this event. How strange God in Christ works in the world! I wait with bated breath for April 30, 2003! She better be careful reading my book, she will turn into another hyper space alienee.

I have several hard to ignore questions about how my book is being handled by the Seguin Guadalupe County Library:

  • If the throwing out of my book was a mere oversight, why is it now such a problem to have it placed upon the shelf?
  • What was in the book Alien Physics that caused the Library Manager to discard it to begin with?
  • Was this because it had Christian cosmology in it?
  • Was it because it had scientific cosmology in it?
  • Was it because I claim to be a hyper space alien in the book?
  • Why does it take 90 days for the Library Manager to review Alien Physics?
  • Does the Library Manager take 90 days to review every book that gets on the shelf?
  • Why did the Head Librarian consult with the Library Manager and go along with her?
  • What is the position of Public Library Board on this book Alien Physics?

    2/10/03 7:00 PM
    City Editor to help:

    2/10/03
    Ron
    ,

    I talked with the library director over there, Mark Gretchen after reading your letters. I would recommend that you go and talk to him about the problem. I've dealt with him on a number of occasions from everything to news coverage to editorial columns that I've written during my tenure here. It's my opinion that you won't find a more fair person and a stauncher defender of the First Amendment and freedom of speech than Mr. Gretchen.
    If after speaking with him you don't feel like any progress has been made and still wish to write a letter perhaps we can talk about the best way to put these three items together in a way that will get your point across.

    Thanks,
    Chris Lykins
    Gazette-Enterprise
    web@seguingazette.com

    2/10/03
    Dear Chris,
    Thank you for your time in dealing with this most interesting development. Maybe you could tell me what Gretchen said about those letters I sent you. I am a little tired of dealing with the Library. Ms. Gross spoke to Gretchen on the phone while I was in her office. Why would he be any help? He knows all about it and could have done something while I was in her office. Isn't this all about Public Relations and stalling and humiliating the stupid resident by those who just have so much more intelligence than other folks. Don't forget that Ms. Gross has already thrown out one of my books into the street. And she wants to read every word of the new one I gave her before she puts it on the library shelf. She is going to check it for accuracy. Mr. Gretchen knows all about this and has probably read my website too. So what is the problem? Please let me know what you know, then I will determine the necessity of calling Mr. Gretchen.
    Sincerely,
    Ron

    2/11/03 2:29 PM
    Ron,

    We actually didn't talk about the letters to the editor that much other than the fact that we had received them. To be honest I don't see this as a PR move on their part. I called Mark, they didn't call me. I have what I consider to be a fairly good relationship with him having dealt with him in the past on other fronts and figured I would pick up the phone and see if I could unravel this.
    The bottom line is the library gains nothing from "stalling and humiliating the stupid resident" as you put it. I don't know Ms. Goss from Eve but as I said I believe Mr. Gretchen is man of integrity and honesty and I think you'll find the same if you simply give him an opportunity.
    For that all you have to go on is my word, for whatever that's worth. I've been at the G-E here almost five years now and I've met some of the best and worst that the Seguin area has to offer. I happen to believe Mr. Gretchen is on the right side of the scale.
    I think he can address your concerns and perhaps explain his view of the situation in a manner that might better fit your expectations. Just give the guy a shot is all I ask.
    If it doesn't work, the other option will of course always remain...

    Chris

    2/11/03
    Dear Chris,
    What do you expect him to do? Do you really think he's going to go tell Ms. Gross (not Goss) to put the book on the shelf right now or do you think he's going to tell me to have patience with the long bureaucratic process? This issue, in fact, has already been resolved as far as the Library is concerned. Ms. Gross threw out the first copy of my book because it didn't fit the "local reading public tastes" and she is going to take until April 30, 2003 to determine if my book has gotten better now that I have challenged her over it. Why should I get Mr. Gretchen involved any more than he's already involved? He knows about it. You talked to him about it. If he doesn't like the way it's going he can intervene and tell Ms. Gross to get the book on the shelf and quit messing around.

    Sincerely,
    Ron Avery
    www.AlienPhysics.com

    2/11/03
    Ron,

    With all due respect, I think Mr. Gretchen wants to talk to you about it. I think that's why the opportunity was offered. I think people like Ms. Gross have bosses for a reason. If I'm upset with an aspect of a system I go to the highest level possible to get a resolution. I don't dither around with people who seem unwilling to do what's necessary. Right now Gretchen is getting Ms. Gross's side of the story. Yours is different and you have the chance to present your side and let the matter be decided like it's supposed to.
    If you talk to Mark and don't like what he has to say and can't come to some sort of resolution then fine. You followed the rules, the chain of command and you feel the system has a problem. We get Letters to the Editor about that type of activity all the time and I'll run them until the cows come home.
    The problem I have is that I've tried to get this thing solved by using my knowledge of the situation and those involved. My goal from the start was to try and solve the problem. If you're interested in getting the problem resolved I've given you a possible avenue to get it done. Whether you avail yourself of that opportunity is up to you. What do you have to lose?
    Chris

    Dear Chris,
    I just wonder what a newspaper should do in this situation.
    Sincerely,
    Ron Avery
    ET - Hyper Space Alien
    www.AlienPhysics.com

    Dear Chris,
    You mentioned the "rules" and the "chain of command." But we know that there is only one woman who has full and complete authority to determine what book goes on the shelf. She said it would take her until April 30, 2003 to determine if my book would go on the shelf. What does Mr. Gretchen do there with the "rules" and "chain of command?" Was Ms. Gross telling me a lie or what?

    Sincerely,
    Ron
    www.AlienPhysics.com

    From Chris Lykins 2/12/03:

    I think Ms. Gross has a boss. I think Mark Gretchen is her boss. Therefore I think whatever her line of reasoning or her beliefs about her power and authority, they all come under the discretion of Mr. Gretchen. If the guy in charge wants to talk to you, you might as well take advantage of it.
    As for a newspaper's role in a situation like this, I think it comes down to the person. I have always viewed the G-E as part of the community. Just because that's so doesn't mean that we wear rose-colored glasses and print whatever the city/county would like and sit on the bad news. But I also take it to mean if I can make a difference, solve a problem, make Seguin a little bit better of a place, then I guess I did alright for the day..

    Sincerely,
    Chris

    2/13/03
    Dear Chris
    ,
    I finally talked to Mr. Mark Gretchen, the head librarian at the Seguin Guadalupe Co. Public Library, on Thursday 2/13/03 at 3:00 PM and he informed me of what the library position is that their manager is reviewing the placement of the book on the shelf and will have an answer "no later than April 30, 2003." This was also my understanding so we did not talk at length at all but merely agreed that this was the situation. He spoke highly of you, as I said you did of him.
    Sincerely,
    Ron Avery
    ET Hyper Space Alien
    www.AlienPhysics.com

    2/13/03
    Ron
    ,
    Is there any chance I can borrow a copy of the book?
    Chris

    Sure Chris,
    If you will read it and give a 500 word written review of it, I will give you a copy.
    Sincerely,
    Ron
    PS I will even sign it

    2/17/03
    I later delivered a book to Chris
    at The Seguin Gazette Enterprise and he said he would review Alien Physics in two weeks and print it in the Guadalupe Scene.

    5/1/03 Thursday
    I went to the Guadalupe County Library and asked Mrs. Gross if Alien Physics had made it to the shelf and she said "yes."

    5/4/03
    Chris told me that the war in Iraq has slowed the reading of my book down greatly and he was still working on it.

    5/14/2014

  • Alien Physics is no longer on the shelf or in the card catalog at the Seguin Public Library.
  • Chris has never contacted me about Alien Physics or printed a review of it.
  • Texas Lutheran University in Seguin Texas placed Alien Physics on the shelf in February 2003 without any problem and cataloged under "cosmology" not "children's books and space invaders" and it is still there and cataloged.

    It's just a matter of talking to the right people who are willing to help. LOL